In
my eyes, there is no “black and white” scenario when dealing with freedom of
expression. This term, presented to Americans by the Founding Fathers, grants
people the right to freely express their own opinions and ideas. Although this
seems very innocent, there have been an extremely large number of instances
where multiple interpretations of this idea have been argued, causing lots of
violence and controversy.
Many
people feel that freedom of expression enables them to say or do anything they
want, literally. An example of
this would be the burning of the American flag. I disagree with this statement
to a certain extent. Susan Brownmiller makes a very good point in “Let’s Put
Pornography Back in the Closet” by discussing how something that is not always
appropriate, such as pornography, should be censored from the general public’s
eyes rather than banned. (Brownmiller 61). That way, people who support
inappropriate things such as porn can express their thoughts in a more
appropriate environment. This gives the viewers a free choice of whether or not
to enter those websites. However, there are many instances where porn is not
censored, such as on the television. I believe the industry does not belong on
there because in many instances, television involves an audience of multiple
people.
In
the article “Protecting Freedom of Speech on Campus,” Derek Bok makes an
interesting point about censorship. He disagrees that censorship should prevent
people from getting offended but feels that campus police are needed for
protecting people (Bok 69). I agree with his views to a certain extent. I feel,
in some cases, that offending people can be very beneficial because it can
expose someone to a different perspective on things. An example of this would
be someone criticizing a southern racist person, arguing how African Americans
have created ingenious genres of music and literature that play a huge role in
America today. Other times, criticizing people to a certain extent is very
harmful to certain groups of society. An example of this is the recent murders
involving Charlie Hebdo in France.
The people who killed these 12 people who considered themselves Muslims hurt
the rest of true Muslims to a certain extent. They failed to realize that these
cartoons were only to help educate the public about the silly reasons of pastime
war in the Middle East. Their actions added to that of 9/11, oppressing Muslims
all around the world.
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/je-suis-charlie-charlie-trends-post-terror-attack-article-1.2068780
Great blog post Kyce. I enjoyed reading this post, I think your introductory paragraph makes a really good point I agree with. The whole there is no "black and white" scenario when dealing with freedom of speech, explains a lot about the complexity of this current issue. One thing I would like to point out is that the burning of an American flag is protected symbolic speech. Although it is crazy and radical the Courts have ruled that actions like these are symbolic speech and are protected by the 1st Amendment. This is one important thing to remember when talking about 1st Amendment protection, even though you and many others might disagree with a certain non-verbal or verbal expression, that doesn't necessarily mean it should be banned or censored. On the issue of pornography, you bring up a good point on how everyone has a free choice on whether or not to look up pornography and how pornography really isn't in your life until you decide to look it up on the Internet. You could stem an argument from this that pornography should not be censored because its in "the closet" and only available when someone seeks after it. Another thing to add is that on TV there are certain laws that pornographic films&shows have to follow such as that they can only be showed late at night so that it is available to adults who seek after it and keeps it off the air when children are watching. In your final paragraph, you bring up one last important point which is that speech although can be offensive or harmful sometimes is an expression of one's beliefs and contributes to the marketplace of ideas. Again it is important to be respectful of other person's beliefs and to be aware of the impact your speech could have on another. Overall great post Kyce.
ReplyDelete